More S’pore residents agree with death penalty for serious crimes like drug trafficking: MHA

More Singapore residents agreed with the use of the death penalty for the most serious crimes here, such as murder, trafficking large amounts of drugs, and firearm offences.

Over three-quarters of respondents, or 77.4 per cent, in the 2023 survey commissioned by the Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA) said they strongly agreed or agreed with this statement.

This was compared with 73.7 per cent of respondents in the same survey done in 2021.

Respondents felt that the death penalty deterred the most serious crimes; that such crimes were serious and posed a danger to society; and that the death penalty was commensurate with the crime, said MHA on Sept 19, when it released the 2023 survey findings.

The survey was done to better understand public perceptions on the death penalty, and was conducted by a survey company appointed by MHA. Face-to-face interviews were conducted with about 2,000 Singaporeans and permanent residents aged 15 and above between April and June 2023.

MHA said the surveys in both 2021 and 2023 used stratified random sampling based on age, race, sex and citizenship status to ensure the survey samples were representative of the national resident population.

To ensure the comparability of the results between both surveys, the questions asked in 2021 were retained in 2023, and the phrasing of these questions generally remained the same.

The 2023 survey found statistically significant increases in the proportion of respondents who strongly agreed or agreed with the use of the mandatory death penalty.

For murder, 85 per cent of respondents strongly agreed or agreed the mandatory death penalty was an appropriate punishment. This was a 4.5 percentage point increase from the 80.5 per cent in 2021.

For firearm offences, this figure was 74.3 per cent in the 2023 survey, compared with 71.1 per cent in 2021.

For trafficking a significant amount of drugs, this figure was 68.7 per cent in 2023, compared with 65.6 per cent in 2021.

Of those who did not agree with the mandatory death penalty, 21.8 per cent preferred the discretionary death penalty, while 56.1 per cent of them chose life imprisonment. The remainder said they did not know.

In 2013, the law was changed to give judges the discretion to impose life terms and caning for drug couriers, instead of death, if specific conditions were met. It would have to be shown, for instance, that the offender acted as a courier and had cooperated with the authorities to disrupt drug-trafficking activities.

According to figures from the Singapore Prison Service, there were five judicial executions in 2023 and 11 in 2022. All 16 were in connection to drug-related offences.

One of the executions in 2023 involved Singaporean Saridewi Djamani, 45, the first woman to be executed in almost 20 years. She was sentenced to death in 2018 for possessing about 30g of heroin for trafficking.

MHA said more than 75 per cent of respondents in the 2023 survey agreed that some form of the death penalty – whether mandatory or discretionary – was appropriate as the punishment for each of the three most serious crimes.

The ministry said this was comparable to the 2021 findings.

Respondents who preferred the discretionary death penalty over life imprisonment said they believed law enforcement authorities or judges were in a better position to decide on the appropriate sentence.

MHA said a close examination of these responses found that while these respondents were open to the death penalty, they trusted the authorities or judges to assess whether the offender deserved it.

Those who preferred the discretionary death penalty also said circumstantial factors needed to be considered during sentencing, which should be decided on a case-by-case basis.

Those who preferred life imprisonment wanted offenders to be rehabilitated and given a second chance.

In the 2023 survey, more respondents agreed the death penalty was an effective deterrent against the most serious crimes.

For drug trafficking, 87.9 per cent agreed with the statement, compared with 83.2 per cent in the 2021 survey.

When asked if the death penalty was a more effective deterrent for drug trafficking compared to life imprisonment, 79.7 per cent of respondents agreed in 2023, a 6 percentage point rise from 73.7 per cent in 2021.

Three new questions were asked in the 2023 survey, with the majority of respondents agreeing or strongly agreeing with the statements posed regarding each of the three most serious crimes here.

An average of 81.8 per cent of the respondents preferred to retain the mandatory death penalty in Singapore; 76.4 per cent felt that replacing the mandatory death penalty with the discretionary death penalty would result in an increase in serious crimes here; while 88 per cent felt the mandatory death penalty was a strong deterrent against the most serious crimes in Singapore.

The ministry said there was a statistically significant increase in the proportion of respondents who strongly agreed or agreed that the mandatory death penalty was a greater deterrent than the discretionary death penalty for the most serious crimes.

For firearm offences, 85.8 per cent of respondents felt this way in 2023, compared with 77.9 per cent in 2021.

Similar to 2021, the majority of respondents in the 2023 survey had confidence that Singapore’s criminal justice system would handle death penalty cases appropriately.

Close to 90 per cent believed that accused persons in death penalty cases are subject to fair and rigorous investigations and trials, while nearly 85 per cent of respondents believed there are adequate safeguards to ensure that there are no wrongful executions.

Source: Straits Times © SPH Media Limited. Permission required for reproduction.

Platform workers deserve better protection – and Singapore is leading the way: Opinion ADV: [webinar] Third-party releases in Restructuring in the US and Singapore (2 October 2024, 1 Public CPD Point)